I have an older greyhound and I give her a treat or two with glucosamine daily for her bones and joints. It really helps out. While she does love food and treats, after I started giving these to her, she follows me into the kitchen to “politely ask” for another. Soft chews so any dog can enjoy them. They really hit the right flavor with these. They can smell it that it has been opened once, so I had to make sure to put it out of reach just in case they wanted to go counter surfing with their nose and mouth.